Skip to main content

"Cheta": My first experience at making cheddar cheese

Last summer I tried my hand at making soft cheese, like chévre, mozzarella, and cottage cheese, from the goat milk we bought from our friend while living in Alaska. I loved how easy the chévre was to make because it required no cooking, and it soon became my favorite thing to make with our extra milk. 

This fall I was a little braver and tried my hand at making raw cheddar cheese, something I have wanted to do for over a year. Now that I have a press, I was able to have a go at it. 


In my experience, making raw cheeses takes patience as you heat the milk on the stove SLOWLY so that it doesn't get above 102° F in order for the beneficial enzymes to stay intact. For this reason, I had set aside a full day so that I had no distractions as I turned 2 gallons worth of milk into cheese. 

After the time on the stove, I pressed the curds in the cheese press for the allotted amount of time and then I eventually waxed it. Then I let it age at room temperature in our cupboard for 4 weeks. The pictures below show what it looked like when we opened it up. I was nervous and excited to try it!

As in most first time experiences, some things I did correctly and other things I...learned to do differently for my next try next week. You win some and you lose some, but at least this cheese was edible. I call that a success!


The first mistake was that our cheese had too much moisture in it. You aren't supposed to wax cheese with so much liquid. It had a strong taste, though not unpleasant. We were going for a "mild cheddar" because it was only aged for 4 weeks, but it tasted more like a "sharp cheddar." My guess is it was too hot in my house. 


This cheese reminds me of feta cheese, hence the name "cheta" in the title. :)

It does not melt well AT ALL, but tastes delicious sprinkled over a salad or even as a last addition to pizza.

Even though it didn't turn out how we were expecting, we sure aren't going to waste nearly 2 pounds of raw goat cheese. 


Because the cheese was too moist, it fell right out of the wax. 
At least it made for easy eating!


What I am going to change for next time:

  • Dry the cheese out longer before waxing.
  • Make sure the cheese is at ROOM TEMPERATURE before waxing to avoid condensation.
  • Wax in 1/2 lb or 1 lb blocks instead of a giant block.
  • Try, try, and try again until it is better. I am no quitter!
Pressing Times:

  1. 12 lbs for 30 minutes 
  2. remove cheese & flip 
  3. 35-45 lbs for 12-15 hours 
  4. remove cheese, change cheesecloth, and flip
  5. 50 lbs for 24 hours


Sites with good information:
Raw Cheddar Cheese Recipe I followed
Another Recipe
Tips for a successful cheese-making experience
Is waxing your own cheese safe?

And always remember that in everything you do:
Our greatest glory is not in never falling but in rising every time we fall. 
--Confucius

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hoping for a Rainbow

I'm really not sure if I ever thought this day would come. The day that I made it past 13 weeks pregnant without losing the baby. #miracle.  I know I am not out of the woods yet, and honestly, when are we really? I am just trying to live every day with gratitude for the life inside of me, living with hope for the future.  Part of me wanted to wait until next week, when I was past 14 weeks and officially in the 2nd trimester, but I couldn't wait any longer. I've been getting a little thick in the middle, which is getting more difficult to hide, and I feel like I haven't been able to be completely honest with friends when they would ask, "how are you doing?" All I wanted to talk about was how nauseous I was or how nervous I felt. So now, the news is out, whether or not you already suspected something was up.  Seriously though, the 1st trimester is not for the faint of heart! There were many instances when I thought I would lose the baby, but dee

I'm Pregnant! .....

...or so I thought. And you did too. Happy April Fools Day! I had been having baby dreams and feeling nauseous on and off during spring break, and I knew I would test immediately when I returned home from our road trip. The test was barely visible and I didn't believe it, so I said nothing to Marshall. That night I had a dream where the next pregnancy test I took was a solid double line. Well, two days after the first test, I got my obvious positive. I was so excited. Not knowing if it would be a good pregnancy or not, I tested again two days later and the line was darker, so I felt confident.  The past two pregnancies I miscarried at approximately 6 or 7 weeks both times, so I was pretty nervous about this one. What if it happened again? Would I be strong enough? Knowing that I needed extra strength and prayers, I asked roughly 40 of our family and closest friends to fast and pray with us on Easter Sunday. That Sunday I was on the top of the world. I felt so strong an

Grandpa is Always Right | Gender Reveal |

I was hanging out in our rental apartment in Salzburg, Austria with my sister when my dad walked out of his bedroom and announced that I was having a girl. I was only 11 weeks along at that point and while I was wishfully hoping for a girl, I was preparing myself for a boy. His strong conviction of the gender of our child without any hints from an ultrasound surprised me. My dad seems to always be right about things, so I secretly hoped he was right this time too. Today during my scan, my favorite sonographer announced that we were having a girl. Grandpa is always right. I never imagined our family starting with a baby boy. I don't know why, but a baby girl seems to fit just perfectly. Now I just have to keep calm and stay healthy for 19 more weeks.